Feedback from authors after they read their report, in their own words, with their names and book titles.
The content of the report was helpful, constructive and specific enough to lead to the type of changes that make a manuscript better for the readers. The tone was positive, polite, and pleasant with no "you made a stupid mistake therefore, you are stupid" undertone. But then, most AI apps are polite!
On the whole I was happy to find your service and satisfied with the report. After three beta readers, four different types of editing software and a costly developmental edit, your report had new, actionable information on each chapter. Surprisingly, it was insightful and knew more about Christianity than any of my other editing software.
Thanks again for providing such a valuable and useful service at an affordable price.
Thank you for sharing the manuscript review and for attaching the report as well. I appreciate the time and effort your team put into the analysis. The report was very thorough and insightful, and honestly much better than I expected. It provided a helpful perspective as I continue refining the manuscript.
…
I also want to acknowledge how quickly you responded when I encountered the upload error. Your responsiveness was greatly appreciated and very reassuring.
…
Overall, I am very happy with the service and the quality of the report.
Thank you again for your support and for building a tool that can be helpful for authors. …
I'm very happy with the review and intend to do my other finished books.
… The cost of having a human being provide any sort of feedback is prohibitive.
I fancy myself as a writer and have solicited reviews of my work from people I know and, in a couple cases, from high-profile professional writers. It’s all very demoralizing. It’s also very expensive.
The AI review bolstered my hope.
I continue to respect what AI says. Its criticisms seem pretty much on as well.
I appreciate your email. The analysis was certainly worth it… As a self-publisher, I ran each paragraph through ChatGPT (I couldn't and won't pay 1000s to have my manuscript stripped of my voice, cadence, etc.), however, the service you offered was more broad and thematic (which is what I was looking for). I would definitely use your service again!
I am currently working through the recommendations made by the report.
I was quite impressed with the detail and suggestions. The review is very comprehensive with lots to work through.
I think it will be great value for money once I have updated the draft.
The recommendations I received from Manuscript were very good, and I adopted some of them.
Thank you very much.
Original review, translated above
Las recomendaciones que recibí de Manuscript fueron muy buenas y acogí algunas de ellas.
Muchas gracias.
Quotes are taken from authors' emails and shared with their permission. … marks where we cut for length, and the Spanish review is our translation.
No subscriptions, no hidden fees. Your report is yours to keep.