Short answer
To get feedback on your book, work through five options, cheapest and fastest first. Edit it yourself, run an AI report, then send it to beta readers. Pay an editor for an assessment or a developmental edit only if readers find a problem you cannot fix.
On this page
The five ways to get feedback, in order
Work down this list. Each step takes longer or costs more than the one before, and none of them sees everything. Editors' prices are for an 80,000-word book. If you are not sure the draft is ready for anyone, run the ten-point readiness checklist first.
| Step | Cost and wait | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Self-editing | Free; a few weeks of your time | What you can measure and fix alone |
| 2. An AI manuscript report | $19; usually under 10 minutes | Notes on the whole book and every chapter |
| 3. Beta readers | Free, or about $150 paid; weeks a round | Where readers got bored, lost or unconvinced |
| 4. An editorial assessment | $1,200–1,440; wait set by the editor | An editor's diagnosis, in a letter |
| 5. A developmental edit | $3,200–4,000; wait set by the editor | Structure and argument, fixed with an editor |
Readers tell you where the book loses them. Editors tell you why. Stop after step 3 unless your readers agree on a problem you cannot fix.
A 12-week plan
Give yourself 12 weeks, and change the draft after every round. If two readers see the same unfixed draft, you pay twice for the same note.
- Weeks 1–3: edit it yourself. Work through seven passes, structure first and sentences last.
- Week 4: run the AI report. Fix the structural notes before anyone else reads the draft.
- Weeks 5–9: one round of beta readers. Send the draft to three to five readers, with a deadline and one question per chapter.
- Weeks 10–12: an editor, if you need one. If the readers agree on a structural problem you cannot fix, book an assessment or a developmental edit. Ask for the turnaround in the quote.
Tell every reader and editor what you want from them: structure, argument or reader reaction. Track every note in one spreadsheet, by chapter. When two sources flag the same chapter, fix it first; a lone complaint may be one reader's taste. If your launch is sooner, keep the order and shorten each step.
Self-editing
Self-editing comes first because every fix costs nothing but time. Read the draft seven times, looking for one kind of problem each time, from the shape of the whole book down to single sentences.
It catches what you can check alone: a book or chapters that run long, claims with no source, an opening that is slow to start. Paste a passage into the readability checker to see its reading level. It misses what you are too close to see, such as the step you skipped because you already know it. Work through the self-editing checklist, then move on.
An AI manuscript report
The Manuscript AI report reads the whole manuscript, a Word file of up to 16 MB, in one run. It usually arrives in under 10 minutes and is guaranteed within 2 hours. It answers eight editorial questions about the book:
- the main message
- the writing style
- the flow between chapters
- the author's personality
- accessibility
- chapter openings and closings
- the reader's next step
- how easy the concepts are to follow
For every chapter it gives a summary, recommendations, the word count, reading time and two reading-level scores. It also answers your own questions about the book. Run it before your beta readers, so they read a draft with the structural problems already fixed.
It does not check facts, edit lines or tell you how a real reader feels. For notes on a single chapter, or rewrites, ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini will do that well. Your file is deleted within 48 hours of delivery and never used to train AI; how we keep your book safe has the detail. To see what you get, read a sample report on Atomic Habits.
Beta readers
Beta readers are ordinary readers who read the finished draft and tell you how it landed. They catch what no tool can: where they skimmed, which claim they doubted, what they would tell a friend the book is about.
They rarely tell you why. A reader says chapter 6 dragged but not what to cut. A round takes weeks, and not every reader finishes. Before you start, read where to find beta readers and what to ask them.
An editorial assessment
An editorial assessment is an editor's letter on the whole book: what works, what does not and what to fix first. There are no edits in the text, so you make every change yourself.
It catches what a reader cannot name: a structure that does not hold, an argument that skips a step, a chapter in the wrong place. Before you book, ask whether the editor reads the full manuscript or a sample, and whether a call about the letter is included. For what it covers and when it is enough, see what a manuscript assessment is.
A developmental edit
A developmental edit is the last and most expensive step: an editor works through the book's structure and argument with you, chapter by chapter. Buy one when the cheaper steps agree the structure is broken and you cannot see how to fix it.
Before you book, ask for the editor's non-fiction titles and an example of their notes. For what the editor does, see what a developmental edit includes.
A developmental edit does not fix typos; a copyedit and a proofread do that later, and you pay for them on top. For those prices, see what a book editor costs.
FAQ
Where to get my manuscript reviewed?
Find beta readers in the Goodreads Beta Reader Group, Reddit's r/BetaReaders or a critique site, or run an AI report in minutes. Find editors through the Editorial Freelancers Association's directory or a marketplace such as Reedsy. Start with the cheapest option that answers your question.
How much does feedback on a book cost?
Feedback on a book costs anything from nothing to about $4,000 for an 80,000-word book. Self-editing and beta-reader swaps are free, and the money goes on editors. That is why the plan above brings one in only when readers agree on a problem you cannot fix.
Where do I start if I don't know how to get feedback on my book?
Start by editing the draft yourself, then run the report before beta readers see it. Bring in an editor last, once you know what you want them to find.
Beta readers or editor first: which should I get?
Beta readers first. They show you where the book loses people, and an editor is better spent once you know which problems readers keep finding. The exception is a structure you already know is broken: take that to an editor and save your readers for the fixed draft.
Where to go next
- Next in Ready to publishThe self-editing checklistSeven editing passes, in the order that saves the most work.
- Beta readers for non-fictionWhere to find them, what to ask them, and what they cost.
- Manuscript assessmentWhat an editorial assessment contains, with an example.
- Developmental editingWhat a developmental editor does, what one costs, and when you need one.
